I had watched 'Memorial' weeks ago when I first set down to write this entry, and, well, nothing stuck. This is the second time I've watched a Voyager episode in this countdown and came away going, "Yeah, okay, fine, whatever, that happened." So, for a second time, I had to wonder if there's something in this episode that I missed. And as it gnawed at me -- what's the deal with this episode, why have fans dubbed it worthy to be on this list -- I think the point of the episode is that sometimes there is no clear answer. Voyager takes on a heavy, complex topic, but because this is a space-adventure show, it comes at it a bit sideways.
"Ugh, get on with it, already. Seriously." — Tom Paris |
Tom, Harry, Chakotay and Neelix are returning from a weeks-long mission aboard the Delta Flyer. When they return to the ship they start having vivid and violent dreams about an armed, alien conflict, where they were participants. These visions go from being dreams to waking nightmares where the characters can't tell the dream from reality. Tom has a breakdown in his quarters. Neelix takes his goddaughter hostage in the mess hall. And the whatever-it-is starts to spread throughout the crew. Nightmares and visions of a way no one had fought. Even Janeway starts to feel the effects of the dreams.
As they follow the mystery and backtrack the Flyer's path, they discover an alien beacon, showing a massacre from their history with the events beamed directly into passerby's brains. They find an alien obelisk on a planet, a memorial to the event that happened centuries ago. Anyone in range relives the firefight, so that it's never forgotten.
The show tries to dive into the moral complexity of war. Showing a military police action forcibly removing colonists from their homes, and things get out of hand. The colonists fight back and someone opens fire and violent higgledy-piggeldy ensues. Other than the commander of the military rigidly following orders (which those types are wont to do) and being a dick about it, there's no clear right or wrong here. It's just people caught in the middle of a difficult situation that has spiraled out of control.
Through the characters, they explore PTSD, with Tom, Neelix, and Chakotay playing the roles of soldiers retuning from duty and trying to re-assimilate back to normal life. Tom comes home to his wife, who greets hm with beer, popcorn and television (literally). They fight. Harry returns to work, and finds tasks that should have been routine, horrifying. Neelix has a complete psychotic break and takes the aforementioned hostage, forever changing his relationship with his goddaughter, Naomi. All of this is pretty heavy stuff coming from a show with space lasers, a woman in a silver catsuit, and a Neelix.
"Don't worry, Naomi! I'll protect you from the nothing!" — Neelix |
Let's talk about Nelix. Much of my initial reaction to Nelix as a character was responding to his aesthetic. He, like Quark on DS9, is the alien outsider, an excuse to exposit on the state of humanity in the 24th century. Like Quark, his appearance is over-the-top, clownish among the predominantly black uniforms of the rest of the crew. Initially, I didn't care for him. His make-up and faux-hawk hair were on the side of the ridiculous. But past his leopard-goldfish-bulldog appearance, I do like the character. He's charming, optimistic, and brings a bit of color both metaphorically and physically to the show. Ethan Phillips has to do a hell of a job acting through that makeup job, and when he emotes, it can come across as silly. Not here, though. Here, his pain and fear come off as real as a man in a leopard-goldfish-bulldog mask can.
As the crew finds the obelisk, they spend a hot second wondering whether to turn it off. To prevent others from suffering the same fate as the crew. Their decision to leave it be, at first feels like a cop out. Janeway passing the moral buck because it's not her decision to make. But, it's not. And her leaving the memorial be is the right thing to do, so that the pain and loss of the massacre won't be forgotten. The episode is a bit ham-fisted, but sometimes Star Trek is what it is, a space-adventure show.
'Tricorder is reading high-doses of heavy-handed dialog. The OTN readings are off the charts." — Janeway |
Star Trek likes to ask the tough questions. Memorial shows that those tough questions don't always have answers.
--
Next up, we're off the Roswell, New Mexico, for one of my favorite episodes of Deep Space Nine, 'Little Green Men.'
No comments:
Post a Comment